How early warnings about commercial exploitation, misleading marketing and the ownership of agricultural knowledge were reinforced by subsequent research
Who is Vlad Jovanovic?
Jovanovic was an active contributor to the early international aquaponics community, sharing practical experiments and technical knowledge from Serbia. In January 2012, he publicly documented his dual-root-zone cultivation technique, which Stephen Raisner subsequently adopted and popularised. Jovanovic's contribution was independently reported by High Times in 2014 (Jovanovic, 2012a; Sirius J, 2014).
His forum contributions demonstrate a commitment to open experimentation, collaborative learning and freely accessible agricultural knowledge.
Why are his November 2012 comments historically important?
They were made during a critical period in aquaponics commercialisation. Scientific research subsequently identified 2012 as the peak of public interest in aquaponics, followed by declining enthusiasm and growing recognition of its commercial difficulties (Turnšek et al., 2020).
Jovanovic identified problems with commercial education and misleading marketing while the emerging industry was still attracting new customers, investors and entrepreneurs.
Did Jovanovic receive commercial offers relating to aquaponics?
Yes. On 21 November 2012, he stated:
I've done some things and turned down some 'deals' (AP related) recently, that looking at it from a "business mindset" probably seem silly (or downright stupid/naive).
This establishes that Jovanovic had received and rejected aquaponics-related business opportunities. The parties involved, financial arrangements and conditions attached to those offers remain unidentified (Jovanovic, 2012b).
His willingness to reject commercial opportunities on principle is particularly significant given the industry's direction at the time.
Why do these rejected offers deserve further historical investigation?
Because technical knowledge, public reputation and established community relationships were becoming commercially valuable assets. Jovanovic's admission raises legitimate questions about how prominent contributors were approached, recruited and offered opportunities to commercialise their knowledge.
Historical investigation should examine consultancy contracts, endorsement agreements, educational partnerships, intellectual property arrangements and financial relationships that influenced the industry's development.
Were established researchers entering commercial arrangements during this period?
Yes. In January 2011, Nelson and Pade announced that James Rakocy had joined its consulting staff in addition to serving on its advisory board. The company also promoted its Clear Flow systems as the only commercial aquaponics systems endorsed by Rakocy (Nelson & Pade, 2011).
Florida corporate records identify Rakocy and Richard C. Shultz as managers of The Aquaponics Doctor, LLC, established in October 2011.
These documented arrangements demonstrate how university research, scientific reputation, consultancy and commercial endorsement were becoming interconnected.
Was corporate involvement increasing in 2012?
Yes. Aquatic Eco-Systems and Green Sky Growers announced commercial aquaponics training featuring Rakocy in September 2011. Their educational initiative accompanied the expansion of equipment distribution and technical services (The Fish Site, 2011).
In October 2012, approximately one month before Jovanovic's comments, Pentair's acquisition of Aquatic Eco-Systems was reported publicly (Blaalid, 2012).
The growing corporate involvement confirms that Jovanovic's concerns arose during a period of substantial commercial expansion.
What did Jovanovic believe about the ownership of knowledge?
He explicitly supported relationships in which knowledge and experience were shared freely:
I supremely value horizontal power structures (and knowledge is power) where people freely give of their time and share their knowledge freely...
(Jovanovic, 2012b).
His position recognised that agricultural knowledge can empower communities. Restricting access to that knowledge, particularly through unnecessary proprietary arrangements, can create dependence on commercial intermediaries.
Had Jovanovic expressed concerns about commercialisation before November 2012?
Yes. In March 2012, he expressed concern that large commercial interests could undermine independent growers and small agricultural businesses. He questioned whether corporate involvement might eventually produce regulatory and financial barriers that disadvantaged grassroots producers (Jovanovic, 2012c).
His November comments therefore form part of an established position concerning the future ownership, accessibility and direction of aquaponics.
Was Jovanovic concerned about misleading marketing?
Yes. He described being appalled by the products being advertised and the methods used to sell them. He openly acknowledged the presence of scammers within the emerging marketplace and questioned the direction of commercial aquaponics training (Jovanovic, 2012b).
These concerns were expressed by someone actively participating in the community during its formative years.
Did subsequent scientific research validate concerns about exaggerated marketing?
Yes. Turnšek et al. (2020) identified widespread inflated expectations surrounding commercial aquaponics, including poorly substantiated claims about profitability, productivity and resource efficiency.
Their research documented a period of commercial disillusionment, substantial investment barriers and the failure of heavily promoted enterprises.
The problems Jovanovic identified informally in 2012 subsequently became subjects of peer-reviewed economic research.
What did Jovanovic predict would happen to misleading commercial offerings?
He expected unreliable products and misleading marketing to be exposed and rejected by the community.
His expectation depended upon consumers recognising unsupported claims and researchers establishing reliable evidence. Fourteen years later, scientific scrutiny remains necessary because promotional confidence can persist independently of agricultural performance.
Did aquaponics become an industry primarily concerned with producing food?
Food production became only one part of its commercial identity. Love et al. (2015), surveying 257 commercial participants, found that 37% sold exclusively fish or plants, 36% combined food sales with related products or services, and 27% sold only aquaponics-related materials or services.
Consequently, 63% participated in commercial activities beyond selling the food that aquaponics was intended to produce.
Was selling aquaponics-related products and services associated with profitability?
Yes. Love et al. (2015) found that respondents selling non-food products and services had approximately twice the odds of reporting profitability.
These activities included equipment sales, consultancy, workshops and agricultural tourism.
The findings establish an important economic incentive: businesses could improve their prospects of profitability by selling the technology and associated knowledge rather than relying exclusively on agricultural production.
Did European research identify the same pattern?
Yes. Turnšek et al. (2020) found that 72% of respondents in their European sample reported income from selling aquaponics knowledge through courses, system design, visits and consultancy. Only approximately 25% reported income from selling food.
Eight years after Jovanovic's warning, independent researchers documented an industry in which commercial knowledge services were considerably more widespread than food sales.
Why was Jovanovic concerned about commercial training courses?
He questioned whether increasingly commercialised educational institutions might eventually concentrate on sustaining themselves rather than fulfilling their original educational purpose. He hoped instructors would genuinely equip students with the knowledge required to succeed (Jovanovic, 2012b).
Subsequent research documenting the prominence of commercial training and consultancy gives this concern considerable relevance (Love et al., 2015; Turnšek et al., 2020).
Can someone teach commercial aquaponics without operating a profitable farm?
Yes. However, instructors claiming expertise in commercial food production should substantiate their knowledge of agricultural economics with realistic production figures, operating costs and financial evidence.
Revenue from courses and consultancy provides no demonstration that the cultivation methods being taught are themselves profitable.
Consumers should understand this distinction before investing in commercial training.
What else was being discussed in the same forum thread?
The original January 2012 question concerned commercial training and Santa Cruz Aquaponics. Participants reported that Santa Cruz had recently ceased operations, citing regulatory difficulties, inadequate funding, labour shortages, competition and miscalculations concerning expected financial returns (Aquaponic Gardening, 2012).
The discussion therefore combined enthusiasm for commercial education with reports of actual commercial failure.
The contrast illustrates why independent financial evidence was already necessary in 2012.
Why are the familiar names appearing in this discussion significant?
Participants included Vlad Jovanovic, Jon Parr, Murray Hallam and Gina Cavaliero. These individuals were active within overlapping aquaponics communities and professional networks.
In August 2011, Sylvia Bernstein publicly identified herself, Cavaliero, Hallam and Wayne Hall as members of the organising committee responsible for establishing the Aquaponics Association (Bernstein, 2011).
These connections document a relatively concentrated professional network linking online discussion, education, commercial activities and industry representation.
Why should interconnected commercial networks receive independent scrutiny?
When educators, equipment suppliers, consultants and industry representatives operate within overlapping networks, recommendations can circulate among people with related commercial interests.
Independent scrutiny helps distinguish scientific validation from reciprocal promotion, professional endorsements and commercial networking.
Financial relationships should be disclosed wherever they could influence educational recommendations or product endorsements.
Did Jovanovic's own technical contribution later acquire commercial value?
Yes. His dual-root-zone technique subsequently became part of commercial aquaponics education. Raisner publicly acknowledged Jovanovic's contribution in March 2014, while later promotional publications presented Raisner as the inventor (Raisner, 2014; Harlaut, 2024).
This illustrates another problem associated with commercialising freely shared knowledge: historical attribution can become distorted when technical contributions acquire marketing value.
Did Jovanovic oppose everyone who charged for agricultural education?
No. He acknowledged that some courses and instructors deserved financial support. His concern was whether education genuinely served students or became primarily concerned with perpetuating its own commercial existence (Jovanovic, 2012b).
The distinction concerns educational integrity, demonstrated competence and accountability.
Why have market forces failed to eliminate unsupported claims more quickly?
Suppliers can generate revenue from attracting new participants even when existing growers struggle to establish profitable farms. Education, equipment and consultancy can be sold before customers complete a single production cycle.
Love et al. (2015) and Turnšek et al. (2020) demonstrate the economic importance of these separate revenue streams.
The financial success of suppliers can therefore coexist with poor agricultural outcomes among their customers.
What responsibility do agricultural educators have?
They should communicate established scientific knowledge accurately, preserve historical attribution, disclose commercial interests and distinguish demonstrated results from experimental ideas.
Claims of profitability, sustainability and superior productivity require independent evidence. Consumers deserve realistic information before committing money, time and resources.
Why does this matter for food and water security?
Agricultural knowledge has substantial public value. Communities facing resource insecurity need affordable, dependable technologies and access to accurate information.
The original NCSU Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs) research demonstrates a different tradition: publishing experimental findings and developing resource-efficient food production with applications in limited-resource communities (Gross, 1988; McMurtry et al., 1997).
Agricultural education should preserve and distribute such knowledge while helping growers reduce unnecessary costs and dependencies.
Conclusion
Vlad Jovanovic's November 2012 comments constitute an important historical warning about the commercial direction of aquaponics.
At the height of public enthusiasm, he identified questionable marketing, commercial exploitation and the danger of educational institutions prioritising their own survival over the success of their students. He also disclosed that he had rejected aquaponics-related business offers.
Contemporary records document the growing involvement of commercial consultants, equipment suppliers, corporate interests and scientific endorsements. Subsequent peer-reviewed research established that selling equipment, education and consultancy became prominent sources of industry revenue, while profitable food production remained difficult.
Fourteen years later, his warnings deserve renewed attention.
Jovanovic recognised that distinction in 2012. The subsequent scientific and economic record demonstrates why it remains important today.
References
Historical forum discussions
-
Aquaponic Gardening (2012). Commercial course. Discussion initiated by Kim, 6 January 2012, including reports concerning Santa Cruz Aquaponics and commercial training.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/commercial-course -
Bernstein, S. (2011). Aquaponics Association Charter. Aquaponic Gardening forum, 26 August 2011. Identifies the association's organising committee.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/aquaponics-association-charter -
Jovanovic, V. (2012a). Dual Root Zone (possible for AP). Aquaponic Gardening forum, 25 January 2012.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/group/fish-less-systems/forum/topics/dual-root-zone-possible-for-ap -
Jovanovic, V. (2012b). Response to Commercial Course. Aquaponic Gardening forum, 21 November 2012, 10:48 am. Preserved in documentary screenshots.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/commercial-course?commentId=4778851%3AComment%3A418648 -
Jovanovic, V. (2012c). Response to Commercial aquaponics.. viable or not.. and why? Aquaponic Gardening forum, 13 March 2012.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/commercial-aquaponics-viable-or-not-and-why?groupUrl=&page=12 -
Raisner, S. (2014). Response published under Steve R in Is Aquaponics The End Goal? Aquaponic Gardening forum, 20 March 2014.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/is-aquaponics-the-end-goal
Commercial and institutional records
-
Blaalid, G.-E. (2012). Pentair's Aquatic Systems Business Acquires Aquatic Eco-Systems, Inc. Fish Farming Expert, 16 October 2012.
https://www.fishfarmingexpert.com/archive/pentairs-aquatic-systems-business-acquires-aquatic-eco-systems-inc/1338264 -
Florida Department of State (2011–2012). The Aquaponics Doctor, LLC. Corporate registration L11000118532. Established 17 October 2011; voluntarily dissolved 18 September 2012.
https://search.sunbiz.org/ -
Nelson & Pade, Inc. (2011). Big News, Exciting Developments. Company announcement concerning Rakocy's consultancy, advisory position, system endorsement and commercial expansion.
https://aquaponics.com/nelson-and-pade-blog/big-news-exciting-developments/ -
The Fish Site (2011). Guest Expert Speaker At Aquaponics Workshop. 28 September 2011. Announcement of commercial training involving Aquatic Eco-Systems, Green Sky Growers and James Rakocy.
https://thefishsite.com/articles/guest-expert-speaker-at-aquaponics-workshop -
Sirius J (2014). Marijuana Aquaponics Classes Start This Weekend. High Times, 26 September 2014. Documents Jovanovic's introduction of DRZ to The Aquaponic Source.
https://hightimes.com/grow/marijuana-aquaponics-classes-start-this-weekend/ -
Harlaut, P. (2024). Interview de Steve Raisner, spécialiste de l'aquaponie symbiotique et de la culture sur sol vivant. Aquaponie France, 14 February 2024.
https://www.aquaponie.fr/interview-de-steve-raisner-le-specialiste-du-chanvre-en-aquaponie-et-sol-vivant/
Scientific research
-
Love, D. C., Fry, J. P., Li, X., Hill, E. S., Genello, L., Semmens, K., & Thompson, R. E. (2015). Commercial aquaponics production and profitability: Findings from an international survey. Aquaculture, 435, 67–74.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2014.09.023 -
Turnšek, M., Joly, A., Thorarinsdottir, R., & Junge, R. (2020). Challenges of commercial aquaponics in Europe: Beyond the hype. Water, 12(1), 306.
https://doi.org/10.3390/w12010306 -
Gross, H. D. (1988). The Aqua-Vegeculture System. North Carolina State University, Office of International Programs.
https://iavs.info/the-aqua-vegeculture-system/ -
McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., Hodson, R. G., Haning, B. C., & St. Amand, P. C. (1997). Efficiency of water use of an integrated fish/vegetable co-culture system. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, 28(4), 420–428.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-7345.1997.tb00290.x