This page is the notice
Dr Mark R. McMurtry told his correspondent to stop treating the false record politely. His examples were a legal warning, a scientific-fraud notice to the editors of the journals involved, or plain speech in place of tolerance. He then stated that he still holds the iAVs name and the iAVs technology, and that abusing, relabeling, renaming, hijacking, mutating, or swallowing that name and technology could be treated as theft.
This page is that notice. It states his claim in his words, states what the claim means, names the publications that do the things he listed, and states the correction those publications now require. It is a warning to editors. It is not a filed lawsuit, and it is not a judgment.
Part I — What he claimed, and what the claim means
Personal communication MC-216-S07. Spelling is left as he wrote it.
What did McMurtry say should be done?
He said the polite version had failed. The next step, in his words, was gravel or a sledgehammer.
“FWIW, If throwing sand into gears of the fraud machine doesn’t slow it down/F it up, then maybe try gravel … or a sledgehammer. E.g., threaten legal action, send scientific fraud notices/warning to relevant journal editors, or get nasty in lieu of polite/tolerant, or ? BTW, I do legally/techically retain all rights to the iAVs name and technology. For others to abuse, misappropriate, relabel, rename, hijack, mutate, pervert, subsume it, etc. could be perceived as theft of intellectual property and related technology - and IMO would/should technically actionable - in the US, but globally? OTOH, once the horses have left the coral, there is no point in closing the gate. Apparently, either Sumitomo just don’t give a flying micro-fuck or are blissfully/intentionally ignorant of their trademark being savaged both in what passes for ‘science’ these daze and in the so-called ‘social media’.” [1]
The sentence before the rights claim is an instruction. Send the editors a fraud notice. Drop the tolerant tone. Treat the conduct as something a United States claim could be built on.
The sentence after it limits what he was willing to do himself. He wrote that the horses had already left the corral. He was not offering to spend what remained of his life on a suit. The record does not need him in the courtroom for the editors to correct it.
What does “retain all rights to the iAVs name and technology” mean?
He claimed two things, and he kept them together.
The name is Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System, abbreviated iAVs. He says that name was formally recorded as his invention in late 1985 by TULCO, the Triangle University Licensing Consortium of Duke, North Carolina State University, and the University of North Carolina. [2]
The technology is the method that name identifies. Fish are fed. Tank water carrying dissolved wastes and solid wastes is delivered to a draining sand bed. The sand is the mechanical filter, the biological filter, the place the solids are held and mineralised, and the crop root zone. Drainage returns to the fish. That is the system investigated at North Carolina State University and published by McMurtry and his colleagues. [3–7] The authoritative list of those papers is the iAVs Research Group page. [8]
“Legally/technically” is his claim that this record still lists him as the holder. The correspondence is his statement. It is not, by itself, a patent certificate or a trademark registration for the word iAVs, and this notice does not pretend that it is.
What use did he say remains free?
The right he describes keeping is the right he used to stop other people locking the method up.
He says iAVs has been open-source since 1985, and that it is not for sale. People may learn it and build it. He says that release was deliberate and that it stands. [9][10]
He says the method was developed and protected so that it would stay open for people who need to produce food. [11]
He says he gave it away, and that he blocked multinational agribusiness from securing proprietary rights in it. He also says North Carolina State ended his position because he prevented a sale of rights in what later got called flood-and-drain, including a proposed transfer toward ADM, in 1986. [12][13]
Read together, the statements are one position. Use of the original method is released. Authorship of the name, and the refusal to let a university office, a company, or a later promoter take the method as property, are what he says he still holds. A person who builds the North Carolina system is doing what he says he gave away. A person who renames it, folds it into another brand, or publishes a different apparatus under its name is doing what he called theft.
Which acts did he call appropriation?
The verbs are a list of published conduct, not a ban on construction.
- Abuse and misappropriate. Treat the name, or the method, as someone else’s property or product.
- Relabel and rename. Call iAVs by another name, or call another system iAVs.
- Hijack. He defined this elsewhere as the system being conflated with, confused with, claimed as, and buried inside so-called aquaponics. [14]
- Mutate and pervert. Change the method — gravel in place of the specified sand, rafts, discarded solids, a prepared chemical solution — and present the result as the original.
- Subsume. Swallow the named system into a larger label until it disappears as its own method.
iAVs is not aquaponics. iAVs is not sandponics. Those words are not substitutes for the name he recorded.
What does “actionable” mean, and what does the open gate mean?
“Actionable” is his opinion that a United States claim could be brought: a court could be asked to hear it. He marked the sentence as opinion. “Could be perceived.” “IMO.” “Would/should.” The grammar is missing a verb, and the spelling is his. The meaning is that he considers the conduct a basis for a claim in the United States, and that he does not know whether the same would hold elsewhere.
He then withdrew the practical threat against the spread of the method. Once the horses have left the corral, shutting the gate does not bring them back. The name and the method are already in the world. A suit would not put them back in a box, and he said there was no point pretending otherwise.
That limit covers retrieval. It does not cover lying. Editors can still stop a journal from calling a fertilizer system, or a modified sand bed, by the name of his invention. They can still require the North Carolina papers to be cited as the prior literature. They can still refuse to let a 2022 or 2024 result travel under the iAVs name.
This notice does not announce that a case has been filed. It does not announce that a court has agreed with him. It records his position, and it performs the act he named that a public scientific record can perform: the fraud notice.
Why is Sumitomo in the same sentence?
He turned from his own name to a name he says belongs to someone else. Sandponics, in his account, is a Japanese corporation’s patented and trademarked hydroponic method: sand, inorganic nutrient solution, and no requirement for fish. [15]
Sumitomo Electric’s own technical reviews describe that product. Baba and Ikeguchi (2015) describe industrial sand cultivation with drip irrigation and a liquid-fertilizer diluter, and they date commercial sales to 1979. A 2017 Sumitomo review dates the product to 1977. Fish are absent from both descriptions. [16][17] Those papers are evidence of what Sumitomo Sandponics is. They are not evidence about iAVs.
A United States registration, SANDPONICS, registration number 5409239, serial 87279671, was issued to Sumitomo Electric Industries, Ltd. on 20 February 2018. A secondary database, retrieved for a related record on 20 November 2026, reports cancellation on 30 August 2024. Official status is the Trademark Status and Document Retrieval entry for that serial. [18][19] Cancellation of a United States registration, if the official record confirms it, does not transfer the word to the North Carolina fish-and-sand method.
McMurtry’s point in the sentence is blunt. A company he believes holds the mark has, in his view, ignored the misuse of that mark in papers and on social media. He was not waiting for Sumitomo to defend his invention. The scientific record is false whether or not the mark-holder sues. Calling the North Carolina system sandponics erases his name and assigns the system a name that belongs to a fertilizer method with no fish.
Part II — The publications that do what he named
These papers are cited for their names, their equations of terms, and their novelty claims. They are not verified as iAVs studies. Their yields, water-use figures, and nutrient results are not iAVs results.
What is the fraud this notice identifies?
A scientific-fraud notice, in the sense he used, is a warning that a paper misstates what was studied, who established it, and what it may be called.
The false statement is an identity statement. A later sand bed, or a fertilizer sand culture, is published as if it were the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System, or as if “sandponics,” “iAVs,” and “aquaponics” were three names for one method. Where the paper also treats the subject as scarcely studied, the false identity is joined to a false account of priority. The North Carolina experiments and papers already existed. [3–8]
That is appropriation of a recorded name. It is also a false experimental identity. A reader cannot tell which system a number belongs to. McMurtry’s performance claims belong to the North Carolina protocol. They do not belong to an unverified or substantially modified system, and they do not belong to Sumitomo’s fertilizer system.
Sewilam, Kimera, Nasr and Dawood (2022), Scientific Reports
The title is the relabel. A sandponics comparative study investigating different sand media based integrated aqua vegeculture systems using desalinated water. The title joins “sandponics” to “integrated aqua vegeculture systems” as if the second were a class of the first. [20]
The paper grew Swiss chard on fish effluent in sand. The abstract presents the arrangement as a novel technique. The North Carolina fish-and-sand method was recorded in 1985 and published from 1990. A 2022 paper that uses the inventor’s system name, pairs it with sandponics, and calls the subject novel is the act he named: rename, subsume, and erase the prior literature in the same gesture.
The 2022 system is not verified as the North Carolina protocol. Its results do not establish iAVs yield, water efficiency, nutrient cycling, or design. Editors of Scientific Reports are on notice for article 11093, volume 12. The permanent link is https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-15291-7.
A commentary on that conflation is already public. [21] Polite correction has been available. The identity statement remains in the journal.
Nair and colleagues (2024), Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment
Nair, Alsudain, Manoharan, Nishanth, Subramanian, Manga and Jaleel titled their paper Sandponics: A sustainable agriculture solution for food security and resource efficiency in arid regions. They wrote that sandponics is also known as the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System. They cited Baba and Ikeguchi (2015) in connection with sand filtration. [22]
Baba and Ikeguchi describe Sumitomo’s liquid-fertilizer sand culture. They do not describe the North Carolina fish-and-sand method, and they do not establish any iAVs finding. [16]
The 2024 paper is not verified as an iAVs study. Its phrase “also known as” is the subsumption in one clause: the inventor’s name is offered as a synonym for a different word, and a no-fish fertilizer paper is offered as literature for the fish-and-sand method. Editors of the Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment are on notice for article e70033. The permanent link is https://doi.org/10.1002/sae2.70033.
What prior literature did those identity claims pass over?
The North Carolina record is not a rumour and it is not scarce. It includes at least the following, with the research-group index as the canonical list. [8]
- McMurtry (1989), doctoral dissertation, North Carolina State University. Performance of an integrated aquaculture–olericulture system as influenced by component ratio. [3]
- McMurtry, Nelson, Sanders and Hodges (1990). Sand culture of vegetables using recirculated aquacultural effluents. Applied Agricultural Research 5(4): 280–284. [4]
- McMurtry, Sanders and Nelson (1993). Mineral nutrient concentration and uptake by tomato irrigated with recirculating aquaculture water. Journal of Plant Nutrition 16(3): 407–419. [5]
- McMurtry, Sanders, Cure and Hodson (1997). Biofilter-to-tank volume ratios. Journal of Applied Aquaculture 7(4): 33–51. [6]
- McMurtry, Sanders, Cure, Hodson, Haning and St. Amand (1997). Water-use efficiency. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society 28(4): 420–428. [7]
Any paper that equates its own sand bed with iAVs, and then writes as if this literature were absent or thin, has misstated the scientific record. The correction is citation and distinction. The correction is not a licence to import that paper’s numbers into the iAVs record.
What does continued commercial use of the wrong name add?
On 28 June 2025, Hassan Elrakhawy, CEO of Leedana, wrote to Barry Taylor that iAVs is the correct term, and that he could have managed the move away from “sandponics” better. Leedana’s public identity continued to lead with sandponics after that admission. The correspondence and the later public record are set out in the companion article on this site. [23]
That episode matters to editors because university and journal prose often repeats the commercial name. McGill’s Desautels Faculty and the Dobson Centre directory continued to describe the technique as sandponics after the McGill Reporter had corrected one article. A company that has already said the scientific name is iAVs, and that keeps selling the other name, is performing the relabel he described. Journals that adopt the commercial name are publishing it.
What does subsumption under “aquaponics” add?
McMurtry has said, repeatedly, that he did not coin “aquaponics,” that he does not accept it as the name of iAVs, and that the hijacking he regrets includes conflation, confusion, and burial inside that word. [14][12]
On 17 May 2026, Virginia Tech News published “Sand-based aquaponics system offers more affordable path for farming in water-scarce regions.” The article acknowledged the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System and its development at North Carolina State in the 1980s. The headline still filed the work under aquaponics, and the URL filed it under sandponics. [24] Acknowledgement in the body does not repair a headline that places the invention inside two names he rejects.
Research on other sand systems is open to anyone. Publishing those systems under his name, or publishing his system under theirs, is the conduct this notice concerns.
Part III — The correction required
Send this page to the editor with the DOI. Ask for a correction, or for an expression of concern limited to the identity claims.
Who is on notice?
- The editors of Scientific Reports, for Sewilam, Kimera, Nasr and Dawood (2022), 12: 11093, doi:10.1038/s41598-022-15291-7.
- The editors of the Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment, for Nair and colleagues (2024), 3(4): e70033, doi:10.1002/sae2.70033.
- Editors and institutional publishers who repeat either equation, including publicity that calls the North Carolina method sandponics or aquaponics.
- Commercial publishers who keep the sandponics name for this method after being told the name is iAVs.
The authors are on notice as well. A literature review that could find Baba and Ikeguchi could find McMurtry. The North Carolina papers are indexed from https://iavs.info/iavs-research-group/, and the individual papers are linked from that page.
What must the correction say?
- Sandponics is not another name for the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System. Sandponics is the Sumitomo sand culture fed with prepared liquid fertilizer, without fish as a defining part.
- iAVs is not aquaponics. The two words do not identify the same system.
- The prior literature of the fish-and-sand method is the North Carolina State University work of McMurtry and colleagues, recorded as an invention in late 1985 and published from 1990 through 1997. Cite it from the research-group index. [8]
- Sewilam and colleagues (2022) and Nair and colleagues (2024) are not verified iAVs studies. Their figures for yield, water, nutrients, or design must not be reported as iAVs figures.
- A sand bed that departs from the North Carolina protocol — particle size, irrigation schedule, solids handling, or nutrient source — must be described as a departure. It must not be described as the original method under a friendlier commercial name.
- Use of the original method stays free. McMurtry’s release of use stands. The correction is not a request for royalties, a kit monopoly, or a paywall on the 1985 method.
What does repetition after this notice mean?
Republication of the equation, after his statement and after this notice, is the fact he described. Relabel. Rename. Hijack. Subsume. He wrote that this could be perceived as theft of the name and the related technology, and that in his opinion it would be technically actionable in the United States.
He also wrote that he was finished spending his life on the fight, and that closing the gate would not recall the horses. Those sentences release him from being the plaintiff. They do not release an editor from the false identity still standing in the paper.
Build the North Carolina system. Teach it. Cite it under its name. That is the use he says he gave away in 1985 and says he will not withdraw.
Stop publishing it as sandponics. Stop publishing it as aquaponics. Stop publishing other sand beds as if they were it. That is the line he said he still holds, and it is the line this notice now puts in front of the editors.
References
McMurtry’s statements on the name, the release, and the notice
- [1] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-216-S07. Statement that he retains all rights to the iAVs name and technology; instruction to threaten legal action or to send scientific-fraud notices to journal editors; opinion that the named conduct would be technically actionable in the United States; remark that the horses have left the corral; remark on Sumitomo and the sandponics mark. Date unknown. iAVs personal-communications archive. Spelling as written.
- [2] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-031. “iAVs” formally recorded as an invention by TULCO, the Triangle University Licensing Consortium (Duke, North Carolina State University, and the University of North Carolina), in late 1985. Date unknown. iAVs personal-communications archive. See also MC-104-S12, which states that iAVs was registered at NCSU (TULCU) as his invention and open-sourced since 1985. The archive notes the TULCO / TULCU spelling variation.
- [9] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-108-S21. “iAVs is not ‘for sale’ — never has been. iAVs is ‘open-source’ — free to all who want to learn/use it — and always will be — by deliberate intent.”
- [10] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-104-S12. iAVs registered at NCSU as his invention and open-sourced since 1985.
- [11] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-101-S47. iAVs “specifically developed and protected to be and remain open-source” for people who need greater food security.
- [12] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-108-S50. States that he developed, proved, published, and open-sourced the method, and that he prevented multinational agribusinesses from securing proprietary rights in it; states that he gave it away; rejects “aquaponics” as the name of iAVs.
- [13] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-100-S03. States that he was terminated from his North Carolina State position without cause for preventing a sale of proprietary rights in what was later called flood-and-drain, including to ADM or other multinationals, in 1986.
- [14] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-108-S51. Defines “hijacked” as conflated with, confused with, commingled with, claimed as, assumed as, and buried within so-called aquaponics.
- [15] McMurtry, M. R. Personal communication MC-207-S15. “Sandponics” described as a Japanese corporation’s patented and trademarked hydroponic technique using sand and an inorganic nutrient solution.
North Carolina State University iAVs literature
- [3] McMurtry, M. R. (1989). Performance of an Integrated Aquaculture-Olericulture System as Influenced by Component Ratio. Doctoral dissertation, North Carolina State University.
https://repository.lib.ncsu.edu/bitstreams/ceb3dcf4-d255-4a38-af55-fb08d24715c8/download
- [4] McMurtry, M. R., Nelson, P. V., Sanders, D. C., & Hodges, L. (1990). Sand culture of vegetables using recirculated aquacultural effluents. Applied Agricultural Research, 5(4), 280–284.
PDF at iavs.info
- [5] McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., & Nelson, P. V. (1993). Mineral nutrient concentration and uptake by tomato irrigated with recirculating aquaculture water as influenced by quantity of fish waste products supplied. Journal of Plant Nutrition, 16(3), 407–419.
https://doi.org/10.1080/01904169309364551
- [6] McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., & Hodson, R. G. (1997). Effects of biofilter/culture tank volume ratios on productivity of a recirculating fish/vegetable co-culture system. Journal of Applied Aquaculture, 7(4), 33–51.
https://doi.org/10.1300/J028v07n04_03
- [7] McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., Hodson, R. G., Haning, B. C., & St. Amand, P. C. (1997). Efficiency of water use of an integrated fish/vegetable co-culture system. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, 28(4), 420–428.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-7345.1997.tb00290.x
- [8] iAVs Research Group. Canonical index of the North Carolina publications. Individual papers are linked from this page.
https://iavs.info/iavs-research-group/
Sandponics as a separate system, and the papers on notice
- [16] Baba, M., & Ikeguchi, N. (2015). Industrial cultivation using the latest Sandponics system. SEI Technical Review, (80), 104–108. Sales dated 1979. Sand, drip irrigation, liquid-fertilizer diluter. No fish. Not an iAVs study.
https://sumitomoelectric.com/sites/default/files/2020-12/download_documents/80-21.pdf
- [17] Kanazawa, S., Matsuo, K., Baba, M., Misu, H., & Ikeguchi, N. (2017). High quality agricultural production support system by smart sand cultivation device “New Sandponics.” SEI Technical Review, (84), 165–171. Product dated 1977 in this review. Not an iAVs study.
https://sumitomoelectric.com/sites/default/files/2020-12/download_documents/84-30.pdf
- [18] United States trademark record. SANDPONICS. Sumitomo Electric Industries, Ltd. Serial 87279671. Registration 5409239. Registered 20 February 2018. Secondary copy:
https://trademarks.justia.com/872/79/sandponics-87279671.html
- [19] TrademarkElite. SANDPONICS, serial 87279671. Secondary database, retrieved 20 November 2026, reporting cancellation on 30 August 2024. Official status is the USPTO Trademark Status and Document Retrieval record for serial 87279671.
https://www.trademarkelite.com/trademark/trademark-detail/87279671/SANDPONICS
- [20] Sewilam, H., Kimera, F., Nasr, P., & Dawood, M. (2022). A sandponics comparative study investigating different sand media based integrated aqua vegeculture systems using desalinated water. Scientific Reports, 12, 11093.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-15291-7
Not verified as an iAVs study. Cited for the title’s equation of sandponics with integrated aqua-vegeculture systems, and for the novelty claim. It does not establish iAVs findings.
- [21] Taylor, B. (2025). The conflation of iAVs and sandponics: A commentary on Sewilam et al. (2022). Zenodo.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17684492
Same title also at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22946542 and at iavs.info.
- [22] Nair, C. S., Alsudain, M. B. H., Manoharan, R., Nishanth, D., Subramanian, R., Manga, A., & Jaleel, A. (2024). Sandponics: A sustainable agriculture solution for food security and resource efficiency in arid regions. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment, 3(4), e70033.
https://doi.org/10.1002/sae2.70033
Not verified as an iAVs study. Cited for the statement that sandponics is also known as the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System, and for the Baba and Ikeguchi citation. It does not establish iAVs findings.
- [23] How To Kill Robots (2026). Leedana, Sandponics and the Refusal to Correct the Scientific Record. Elrakhawy’s 28 June 2025 admission that iAVs is the correct term, and the later public record.
Leedana, Sandponics and the Refusal to Correct the Scientific Record
- [24] Virginia Tech News (17 May 2026). Sand-based aquaponics system offers more affordable path for farming in water-scarce regions.
https://news.vt.edu/articles/2026/04/cals-bse-sandponics-water-scarce-regions.html