Attribution, Terminology & Food Security

How MyAquaponics, Leedana and Crops by SPC Influence Scientific Attribution, Public Knowledge and Food Security

Introduction

MyAquaponics, Leedana and Crops by SPC have commercially promoted sand-based fish-and-vegetable production using methods substantially derived from the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs), developed by Dr. Mark R. McMurtry and his colleagues at North Carolina State University. Their inconsistent attribution, preference for the ambiguous name sandponics, and limited direction of audiences toward the original research have contributed to an information environment in which commercial brands can become better known than the scientific methodology underlying them. Such practices risk undermining independent learning, research accuracy, food-security initiatives and the original objective of making iAVs freely accessible.

Companies including MyAquaponics, Leedana and CropsBySPC have benefited from promoting sand-based fish-and-vegetable production derived from the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs). Yet their public presentation has frequently prioritised the name sandponics, commercial identities and their own products or services over the original scientific methodology, its inventors and the research archive. This creates an important imbalance: businesses receive visibility, commercial opportunities and institutional recognition, while members of the public and researchers may remain inadequately informed about the earlier scientific work of Dr. Mark R. McMurtry, his North Carolina State University collaborators and the subsequent educational contributions of Gary Donaldson.

Why is the conduct of businesses promoting iAVs-derived technology a matter of public interest rather than merely a disagreement over recognition?

Because the issue concerns access to scientifically established agricultural knowledge originally intended to improve food production, nutrition, water efficiency and economic independence.

The Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System was developed during the 1980s by Dr. Mark R. McMurtry and his colleagues at North Carolina State University.

The researchers investigated a recirculating system that integrated fish production, vegetable cultivation, mechanical filtration, biological nutrient transformation and water conservation.

The sand beds served simultaneously as the growing environment and the biological filtration system.

The technology was investigated through an organised scientific programme and documented in peer-reviewed publications (McMurtry et al., 1990; McMurtry et al., 1993; McMurtry et al., 1997).

The intended applications extended beyond commercial agriculture.

H. Douglas Gross of NCSU's Office of International Programs identified benefits for smallholders, resource-limited communities and developing countries, including improved access to nutritious food and opportunities to produce agricultural income (Gross, 1988).

McMurtry subsequently described his efforts to preserve unrestricted public access to the technology rather than allow it to become controlled through exclusive commercial licensing (McMurtry, 2018).

Consequently, the original research was a public agricultural resource.

When later businesses teach, construct or commercialise substantially similar systems, the way they describe the technology influences whether growers and researchers discover that original resource.

If readers encounter only commercial adaptations, they may never investigate the earlier scientific findings or understand which design specifications were experimentally established.

The central issue is whether commercial dissemination preserves access to the scientific knowledge that makes the technology useful, reproducible and potentially accessible to people facing food insecurity.

Were the principles now promoted as sandponics already scientifically established before MyAquaponics, Leedana and CropsBySPC entered the market?

Yes. The defining features of iAVs were investigated and published decades before these businesses began promoting their commercial systems.

The original NCSU methodology involved fish-tank water carrying dissolved nutrients and suspended organic wastes into planted sand beds.

The sand captured fish solids, provided microbial habitat and supported vegetable roots.

Intermittent irrigation allowed water to drain through the sand and return to the fish tank.

These arrangements were associated with productive fish and vegetable cultivation, nutrient recycling and satisfactory biological filtration (McMurtry et al., 1990; McMurtry et al., 1997).

The researchers also investigated nutrient concentrations, growing-bed ratios, fish growth, plant yields and water-use efficiency.

The resulting studies established a recognisable experimental methodology.

That record is important when evaluating commercial claims concerning sand cultivation.

A company may introduce genuinely useful improvements in construction, automation, software, farm management or local adaptation.

However, the existence of a new company, product name or commercially successful installation does not establish that the underlying biological method was newly invented.

To identify the company's original contribution, the earlier scientific methodology must first be acknowledged.

The foundational engineering principles were already documented in the NCSU research. Later commercial improvements should be distinguished from that prior scientific achievement.

What evidence establishes that these businesses are familiar with iAVs rather than independently developing unrelated systems?

Their own published materials provide direct evidence of knowledge of iAVs.

MyAquaponics published a construction article in December 2021 explicitly identifying its sand-based installation as iAVs, although it primarily used the name sandponics (MyAquaponics, 2021).

Leedana's community page identifies McMurtry and his research team as the original inventors of iAVs.

Its public company description also credits the earlier research and names McMurtry, Douglas Sanders and Merle Jensen (Leedana, 2026a; Leedana, 2026b).

SPC for Advanced Agriculture, associated with the Crops brand, was included in the 2026 AgriTech4Tunisia Innovation Challenge.

The official programme identified the company's proposed method as sandponics and explicitly equated it with the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (AgriTech4Tunisia, 2026).

The iAVs.info documentary archive additionally records correspondence and public statements acknowledging the original research (Taylor, 2026a).

These sources establish that the relationship to iAVs is recognised within the companies' public information environment.

The administrator of iAVs.info also reports having repeatedly contacted representatives of all three businesses, supplied information about the scientific archive and requested more complete attribution. This is first-hand testimony; the complete correspondence is not independently verified here.

The underlying issue is consequently more specific than a simple lack of awareness.

These businesses have publicly demonstrated familiarity with the original technology. Their continuing choices about terminology, citation and source visibility can therefore be evaluated against an identifiable scientific history.

How does MyAquaponics demonstrate the problem of commercial promotion without adequate historical attribution?

Its December 2021 construction guide provides a clear example of the original methodology being promoted primarily through a different name.

The article was titled Sandponics Is Aquaponics on Steroids – How to Build Your Own Sandponics or Sandgarden System.

MyAquaponics described converting a previously established deep-water-culture aquaponics installation into a sand-based growing system.

The company reported that the results were exceptional.

It identified advantages including the elimination of separate mechanical and biological filters, reduced pumping requirements, nutrient recycling and the capacity to grow a wider range of crops (MyAquaponics, 2021).

These benefits closely resemble those investigated in the original NCSU research.

The article did acknowledge iAVs in its opening paragraph.

However, it did not identify McMurtry as the inventor, explain the original research programme or provide citations to the NCSU scientific publications.

Nor did the article direct readers to the iAVs.info research archive.

Instead, readers were repeatedly presented with the name sandponics.

The article also linked directly to growing beds and other components available from MyAquaponics.

It encouraged readers to contact the company for assistance.

This created a commercially useful instructional resource.

However, it provided an incomplete account of the scientific origins of the method being taught.

MyAquaponics demonstrated the commercial and educational appeal of the original iAVs principles while giving readers little practical assistance in discovering the scientists, publications and research methodology from which those principles originated.

Did MyAquaponics reproduce the original Standard Baseline Recommendations accurately?

Its published construction guide contained several identifiable departures from the recommended baseline.

The company described three sand beds approximately five metres long, 1.2 metres wide and 25 cm deep.

The original SRB specifies a minimum sand depth of approximately 30–33 cm.

MyAquaponics also recommended relatively coarse sand particles of approximately 1–3 mm.

Its irrigation programme operated for thirty minutes followed by ninety minutes without pumping during daylight hours.

The guide stated that the growing beds should be level (MyAquaponics, 2021).

By comparison, the original iAVs methodology employed specifically graded sand, raised planting ridges, shallow irrigation furrows, shorter intermittent irrigation periods and a deliberate drainage slope (McMurtry et al., 1997; iAVs.info, 2026).

These differences may influence hydraulic performance, solids retention, moisture distribution and root-zone aeration.

The MyAquaponics installation may still be productive.

Indeed, the company's account reported favourable results.

However, its design cannot automatically be treated as an exact replication of the original experimental method.

This illustrates why attribution must include more than briefly mentioning an acronym.

The original research provides the scientific basis for understanding which dimensions and operating procedures were tested.

Without access to that information, readers may assume that a commercial adaptation represents the original methodology.

Commercial education becomes technically misleading when the distinction between the research-established baseline and subsequent modifications is not made clear.

Has MyAquaponics obtained commercial benefits from presenting this growing method through its own educational and retail channels?

Yes. The company operates a commercial business selling growing equipment, supplies and educational services.

Its website markets fish tanks, pumps, growing beds, water-quality equipment, filtration components, growing media, nutrient products and training courses.

Its sand-based construction article directs readers toward products available from the company, including fibreglass growing beds.

It also provides direct contact information for prospective customers (MyAquaponics, 2021; MyAquaponics, 2026).

The company separately advertises aquaponics and sandponics training programmes.

Its 2024 report concerning an aquaponics project supported by Sappi described a participant in one of its training programmes who helped establish a substantial agricultural installation (MyAquaponics, 2024).

These records establish a connection between technical education, professional reputation and commercial services.

The value obtained from such activities can include direct equipment sales, course fees, consultancy opportunities, customer relationships and enhanced industry credibility.

There is no need to speculate about secret financial arrangements to identify these benefits.

The commercial model is public.

The ethical issue concerns whether a company that benefits from teaching a pre-existing agricultural methodology gives readers adequate access to its origins.

A company can legitimately earn income from implementing public-domain research. That commercial freedom does not eliminate the responsibility to accurately identify the earlier scientific contribution.

Does Leedana publicly acknowledge McMurtry and the original iAVs research?

Yes. Leedana provides an important example of partial recognition combined with continued commercial rebranding.

The company's public community page identifies McMurtry and his research team as the original inventors of iAVs.

It also presents educational resources associated with iAVs.

Leedana's LinkedIn company description credits earlier research associated with McMurtry, Douglas Sanders and Merle Jensen (Leedana, 2026a; Leedana, 2026b).

These acknowledgments should be recognised.

They establish that Leedana has publicly acknowledged the earlier scientific history.

However, the same company prominently markets its technology under names such as Leedana Sandponic and Leedana Sandponics.

Its promotional material emphasises its own branded growing systems, sand products, farm network, software and operational data.

A separate commercial presentation advertises Oasis software, SandSense monitoring equipment and farm-management services (Leedana, 2026c).

Consequently, the central issue is not complete silence.

It is the relative prominence of the original scientific identity compared with the company's commercial identity.

Leedana demonstrates that acknowledging the inventor somewhere within a company's information network does not necessarily mean that the original technology receives consistent recognition throughout its principal marketing and educational material.

Why does Leedana's continued use of sandponics remain controversial even where some credit is provided?

Because terminology influences how a technology is identified, researched and distinguished from other agricultural methods.

Leedana describes an agricultural process involving fish-derived nutrients, sand cultivation, biological filtration and recirculating water.

These are fundamental iAVs principles.

Its public material also describes commercial software, specialised sand selection and farm optimisation.

Those additions may represent useful business or engineering services.

They do not alter the historical identity of the underlying biological production method.

A reader encountering the phrase Leedana Sandponics may understand it as an independently developed agricultural technology rather than a commercial implementation of iAVs.

That risk persists even if a separate community page acknowledges McMurtry.

The administrator of iAVs.info reports having directly requested that Leedana discontinue using the name sandponics and receiving an explicit refusal.

That account establishes the advocate's reported experience but is not independently authenticated through a complete correspondence record here.

The company's continuing public branding is independently visible.

It establishes that Leedana still chooses to promote the alternative term.

Where a company knows the original scientific name and nevertheless gives precedence to a commercial alternative, the resulting attribution and research-discoverability problems deserve direct criticism.

What makes CropsBySPC particularly significant in the debate over commercial appropriation and scientific recognition?

CropsBySPC is connected to SPC for Advanced Agriculture, also known as The Sandponic Collective, whose business model combines agricultural production with farm development and technical services.

The company's website advertises turnkey farm design and installation.

It offers ongoing supervision, crop monitoring and farm maintenance.

Its comprehensive commercial model also provides produce packaging, marketing and distribution under the Crops brand (SPC for Advanced Agriculture, 2026).

These services demonstrate that the company derives commercial value from the growing method it promotes.

The method itself is presented principally as sandponics.

Yet the original iAVs research had already investigated the combination of sand-based biological filtration, fish-derived nutrient recycling and recirculating fish-and-vegetable cultivation decades earlier.

The company's public services do not establish that it invented those principles.

SPC may have developed its own farm-management procedures, local construction practices, distribution arrangements or other improvements.

Those contributions deserve recognition where demonstrated.

However, the commercial application of an existing method should be distinguished from the original scientific invention.

SPC's economic activity demonstrates how a publicly developed agricultural methodology can become the foundation for a separately branded commercial enterprise. The resulting promotion should preserve the identity and provenance of the underlying science.

Did CropsBySPC receive institutional recognition through an innovation programme while presenting its technology as sandponics?

Yes. SPC participated in the 2026 AgriTech4Tunisia Innovation Challenge, associated with CGIAR's Accelerate for Impact Platform.

The official programme's published selection material identified The Sandponic Collective as one of the participating innovation teams.

Its description expressly connected the company's sandponics method with the Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (AgriTech4Tunisia, 2026).

The programme offered business mentorship, technical support, connections with investors, market access and opportunities for further project development.

SPC subsequently appeared in promotional material published by CGIAR's Accelerate for Impact Platform.

The institutional feature described the company's sand-based growing method as an innovation and publicised the company's agricultural activities.

It also reported figures supplied in connection with the company's operations, including farm installations, crop production and water savings (CGIAR A4IP, 2026).

These are meaningful forms of institutional visibility.

They can strengthen commercial credibility and assist a business in obtaining partners, customers and investment.

However, the available public record establishes programme participation and promotional recognition, not that SPC won the competition's top prizes.

The distinction is important.

An enterprise can obtain valuable institutional credibility through an innovation programme even when the original scientific principles underlying its promoted technology were established by other researchers decades earlier.

Why does the AgriTech4Tunisia selection process raise questions about scientific attribution and originality?

Because the programme explicitly considered novelty, scientific relevance and ownership of proposed innovations.

The AgriTech4Tunisia eligibility criteria stated that applicants should be the inventors and rights holders of their submitted solutions.

Its evaluation criteria also required novelty and uniqueness, including contributions that differed from existing technologies and practices (AgriTech4Tunisia, 2026).

These requirements create an important distinction between inventing a technology and developing an original improvement or business model based on that technology.

McMurtry's iAVs was already established in the 1980s.

Its central engineering principles were published in scientific journals.

Consequently, those established principles cannot themselves constitute a new invention by SPC.

The appropriate questions concern which specific features SPC developed independently.

Were these features new growing-bed geometries, control systems, locally adapted construction methods, improved commercial practices or other identifiable innovations?

What experimental evidence demonstrates their novelty and technical advantages?

Were the earlier NCSU studies fully disclosed to the programme administrators?

Were evaluators provided with enough information to distinguish the established iAVs methodology from SPC's original contributions?

The public programme description does not answer all these questions.

It would be inappropriate to infer fraudulent conduct solely from SPC's participation.

However, the combination of an originality-focused programme and the promotion of a clearly pre-existing scientific methodology makes transparent attribution particularly important.

Innovation funding and awards should recognise genuinely original contributions. They should not inadvertently transfer the apparent historical authorship of established public-domain science to later commercial implementers.

Is there evidence that SPC's representatives already knew about McMurtry and the original iAVs research?

Yes. Both its public institutional description and recorded correspondence acknowledge the relationship.

The official AgriTech4Tunisia material explicitly identified the proposed method as iAVs.

The iAVs.info documentary archive also contains statements attributed to SPC-associated representatives acknowledging McMurtry's foundational contribution.

One recorded public exchange involved Rabie Goma responding to an educational video shared by the iAVs advocacy community.

In that exchange, Goma acknowledged McMurtry's research and expressed respect for the work of the iAVs community (Taylor, 2026a).

Other correspondence reproduced in the archive concerns requests for details of modifications that SPC representatives said they had made to the original method.

The archive reports that specific technical documentation was not supplied during those exchanges.

These correspondence records were assembled by the iAVs.info administrator. Their complete provenance depends on the underlying messages and screenshots, which should accompany any formal evidentiary publication.

However, the company's familiarity with the original technology is independently supported by the official AgriTech4Tunisia description.

The relevant debate concerns the adequacy and prominence of attribution, not whether SPC has ever heard of the original scientific research.

What does the reported dispute over recognition of SPC's farm footage reveal about reciprocity?

It illustrates why standards of attribution should apply consistently to scientific origins and subsequent practical contributions.

The iAVs.info documentary record describes a public exchange in which SPC objected to the use of footage showing installations it had constructed or supervised.

The response attributed to Rabie Goma requested recognition of the company's contribution to the physical installations (Taylor, 2026b).

That request concerns a legitimate category of attribution.

A business or grower may deserve credit for constructing a farm, producing photographs or creating original instructional media.

However, the same principle should apply to the historical scientific work upon which those installations depend.

The inventor of a production methodology and the constructor of a particular farm have different contributions.

Both can be recognised without diminishing either.

The contradiction arises when prominent recognition is demanded for commercial implementation while the originating research is identified only intermittently or through a broad alternative name.

The iAVs.info archive also records exchanges requesting that SPC identify and document its claimed technical modifications.

According to the archived correspondence, representatives expressed preferences for communicating through their own professional channels rather than providing the requested details in the public discussion.

That response is not proof of misconduct, but it highlights a genuine difference between an open scientific dissemination model and a commercially managed technical-information model.

A consistent attribution standard should recognise McMurtry and the NCSU researchers for the invention, Gary Donaldson and other educators for dissemination, and later businesses for their documented construction, management and independently developed improvements.

Why is Gary Donaldson's contribution especially relevant to the conduct of these businesses?

Because the dissemination of iAVs depended not only on the original scientific publications but also on people who preserved, explained and made the information accessible.

Gary Donaldson was a prominent advocate and educator associated with the dissemination of the original iAVs methodology.

In February 2021, Murray Hallam publicly identified Donaldson as someone who had published substantial quantities of McMurtry's material and promoted iAVs widely (Hallam, 2021).

The iAVs.info archive subsequently continued this work by preserving research documents, historical records, technical explanations and educational resources.

These activities helped make the original methodology accessible to growers outside academic institutions.

The administrator of iAVs.info reports that MyAquaponics, Leedana and people associated with CropsBySPC learned about the technology through the work of McMurtry and Donaldson.

He also reports having repeatedly provided guidance and requested more substantial public acknowledgment from the businesses.

These statements are first-hand testimony concerning the history of the educational relationships.

The public evidence establishes Donaldson's dissemination role and the businesses' knowledge of iAVs, but the precise training relationship with each individual or company would require supporting correspondence or witness documentation to establish independently.

The ethical issue remains important.

Public-domain scientific education depends heavily on contributors who make information available without requiring commercial returns.

Where a business benefits from educational resources made freely available by others, accurate acknowledgment and useful links back to the original research are reasonable forms of professional reciprocity.

Why does the name sandponics create a problem beyond simply preferring a different word?

Because it has an established history referring to a separate agricultural technology and can obscure the identity of the NCSU methodology.

The name Sandponics was used by Sumitomo Electric Industries for a Japanese sand-based cultivation system developed during the 1970s.

In Industrial Cultivation Using the Latest Sandponics System, Masato Baba and Naoki Ikeguchi explained that Sumitomo Electric commenced sales of its Sandponics system in 1979.

Their technical description identifies a sand-growing medium supplied through drip irrigation with a liquid fertiliser solution (Baba & Ikeguchi, 2015).

That approach differs substantially from McMurtry's iAVs.

The Japanese method was developed as a form of sand-based controlled-environment cultivation using manufactured nutrient solutions.

The original iAVs method integrated aquaculture, fish-feed-derived nutrient recycling, biological waste processing and planted sand biofilters.

Using the same name for both technologies creates an avoidable ambiguity.

A researcher searching for sandponics may encounter literature concerning Japanese chemical-fertigation sand culture.

Another researcher may encounter studies describing modified sand-based aquaponics systems.

A third may be looking for the original NCSU iAVs methodology.

These bodies of literature are not automatically interchangeable.

The problem therefore extends beyond personal preference.

Using a historically established name for a different technology can interfere with literature discovery, technical classification, scientific comparison and correct attribution.

Can repeated commercial use of sandponics contribute to errors in academic research?

Yes. Inconsistent nomenclature can result in researchers identifying the wrong scientific precedent or treating materially different methods as equivalent.

The problem has already been illustrated in university research communication.

In May 2026, Virginia Tech published a news article describing work on sand-based integrated fish-and-plant cultivation.

The original article prominently used sandponics without adequately identifying McMurtry and the NCSU research history.

Following correspondence from the iAVs advocacy community, the university publication was revised to acknowledge the earlier work.

Dr. Natasha Bell, a faculty member associated with the project, explained in correspondence dated 27 June 2026 that her team was familiar with McMurtry's research but had not realised that the two names should be distinguished (Taylor, 2026a; Virginia Tech, 2026).

This example is especially important because the researchers were not necessarily ignorant of the original science.

The problem arose in the public description and categorisation of the work.

It demonstrates how terminology can produce historical confusion even where the underlying research is familiar.

The distinction also matters when assessing scientific studies that use the name sandponics for systems with different growing media, nutrient inputs, irrigation arrangements or fish-production components.

Such studies should not automatically be interpreted as experiments on the original iAVs baseline.

Accurate terminology helps researchers identify the correct prior literature, distinguish established methods from modifications and avoid misleading claims of originality.

How can incomplete attribution harm researchers and scientific progress?

It can interfere with the identification of earlier experiments, duplicate research unnecessarily and produce inaccurate conclusions concerning novelty and technical performance.

Scientific research depends on the continuity of published knowledge.

Researchers are expected to identify relevant prior work and distinguish new findings from established results.

The NCSU programme investigated component ratios, plant mineral nutrition, fish growth, biofilter function, water efficiency and crop yields.

These findings provide useful starting points for subsequent investigations (McMurtry et al., 1990; McMurtry et al., 1993; McMurtry et al., 1997).

If the original research is omitted from technical histories or concealed beneath inconsistent terminology, later investigators may fail to identify this foundation.

They may describe previously studied principles as newly discovered.

They may also select experimental configurations without understanding the reasons behind the original specifications.

A researcher examining a modified system may then attribute poor performance to iAVs even though the design differs substantially from the original methodology.

The result is weaker scientific comparison.

Researchers must spend additional time reconstructing the history, locating earlier publications and determining which systems are genuinely comparable.

This creates an unnecessary obstacle to cumulative scientific progress.

The loss of accurate provenance is a practical research problem. It affects literature reviews, experimental design, technical interpretation and the assessment of original scientific contributions.

How does the failure to direct people toward the original research negatively affect the public?

It restricts the information available to people making decisions about how to produce food.

A prospective grower may encounter sand-based cultivation through a company's website, instructional video or paid course.

That material may explain how to build a system using the company's products or preferred construction methods.

However, it may not provide the original research papers, independent experimental results or Standard Baseline Recommendations.

The difference is significant.

A grower who receives only a commercial explanation has limited information for determining which components are essential, which parameters were tested and which recommendations represent later modifications.

Access to the original evidence allows the grower to evaluate the system independently.

It also makes it easier to distinguish scientific findings from sales claims.

The original iAVs research investigated precisely the issues important to resource-limited producers: nutrient recycling, water conservation, biological filtration and the efficient production of fish and vegetables (Gross, 1988; McMurtry et al., 1990).

A clear reference to the original research archive therefore provides practical value.

It allows readers to locate the experimental method rather than depend entirely on the commercial intermediary.

When a business promotes the benefits of iAVs but fails to provide a clear route to the original scientific evidence, the public receives a less complete basis for making agricultural decisions.

Why does this issue matter particularly for food security, malnutrition and household independence?

Because the original scientific programme was developed to improve access to nutritious food and make productive agriculture more accessible under resource constraints.

Fish and vegetables provide complementary nutritional benefits.

Fish can contribute high-quality protein, essential fatty acids and important micronutrients.

Vegetables contribute vitamins, minerals, fibre and other dietary components.

An integrated production method capable of supporting both can be relevant to households and communities seeking to diversify their food supply.

The NCSU research was explicitly directed toward such applications (Gross, 1988).

The practical value of the method depends on the ability of growers to understand and reproduce it.

If people are introduced only to commercially branded systems, they may assume that specialist products, paid instruction or proprietary management arrangements are necessary.

They may not discover the original method or the possibility of independently constructing a suitable installation.

This can reduce informed choice and increase dependence on commercial intermediaries.

The social consequences should be described accurately.

The available evidence does not quantify how many people have suffered malnutrition or food insecurity because businesses failed to cite iAVs.

Such claims would require direct measurements and causal analysis.

However, the importance of the information gap is clear.

A potentially useful agricultural method is less accessible when its original technical knowledge is obscured or separated from the materials through which most people encounter it.

For people attempting to improve food security and household independence, access to accurate, freely available agricultural knowledge is a practical resource—not merely a matter of academic recognition.

Do these businesses benefit financially or professionally from an audience unfamiliar with the original scientific history?

Their documented business models provide commercial and reputational benefits from presenting the technology through their own channels.

MyAquaponics sells growing equipment and educational services.

Leedana promotes branded growing systems, software, farm management and technology services.

SPC sells farm design, installation, supervision and produce-marketing services.

These activities can generate revenue and develop professional credibility (MyAquaponics, 2026; Leedana, 2026c; SPC for Advanced Agriculture, 2026).

Recognition through industry publications, institutional partnerships and innovation programmes can also increase a business's visibility and attractiveness to potential customers or investors.

The AgriTech4Tunisia case demonstrates this mechanism particularly clearly.

SPC's participation generated public promotion through an internationally recognised agricultural research and innovation network (AgriTech4Tunisia, 2026; CGIAR A4IP, 2026).

The financial value of that exposure has not been quantified.

Nor does its existence prove that the company intentionally concealed information to obtain it.

Nevertheless, commercial visibility and public recognition are real benefits.

A company whose promotional identity becomes closely associated with an agricultural method may acquire an apparent degree of technical authority.

That authority can be strengthened when consumers are unfamiliar with the earlier scientific research.

Commercial and reputational incentives provide a credible reason to scrutinise whether the public is being given the complete history, even when deliberate concealment has not been established.

Why are grant applications, awards and innovation programmes particularly sensitive to incomplete attribution?

Because these programmes frequently evaluate originality, scientific merit, impact, scalability and the applicant's distinctive contribution.

The difference between developing an original technology and commercialising an established technology can be important to an evaluator.

An applicant may legitimately seek support for adapting iAVs to local conditions, developing farm-management software, improving construction or establishing commercial distribution.

Those may be valuable innovations.

However, the application should accurately identify the pre-existing scientific foundation.

Otherwise, evaluators may attribute to the applicant contributions that belong to earlier researchers.

The AgriTech4Tunisia programme explicitly included novelty among its selection criteria.

It also considered scientific relevance and the distinctiveness of proposed solutions (AgriTech4Tunisia, 2026).

These criteria make the NCSU research directly relevant to the evaluation of an enterprise promoting iAVs-derived production.

Transparent attribution would allow evaluators to identify what was already established and what the applicant had actually contributed.

It would also allow public recognition and investment to be allocated with a clearer understanding of the technology's development.

Institutional recognition is most credible when commercial innovation is presented alongside accurate acknowledgement of the scientific work on which it depends.

Does public acknowledgment of McMurtry in occasional statements adequately resolve the problem?

It can improve historical accuracy, but isolated acknowledgment does not necessarily make the wider educational presentation complete.

The relevant issue is whether a typical reader can identify the original methodology and find its scientific foundation.

Leedana's public recognition of McMurtry is meaningful.

MyAquaponics' acknowledgment of the iAVs acronym also provides some historical information.

SPC's institutional material identifies iAVs as a name associated with its method.

These facts should be acknowledged.

However, the value of attribution depends partly on prominence, accuracy and usefulness.

A reader benefits much more from a clear explanation identifying McMurtry, North Carolina State University and the original publications than from a passing mention of an acronym.

Likewise, a direct link to the research archive allows readers to examine the original work themselves.

The central issue is whether scientific provenance is communicated consistently in the principal pages, videos and teaching materials through which new growers encounter the method.

Attribution is most useful when it enables readers to understand the original contribution and independently locate the supporting evidence.

What does the lack of reciprocity toward McMurtry, Gary Donaldson and the iAVs educational archive reveal?

It raises a legitimate ethical concern about the relationship between open scientific dissemination and commercial use of publicly shared knowledge.

McMurtry deliberately promoted broad access to his agricultural methodology.

Gary Donaldson subsequently played a substantial role in distributing and explaining the research.

The iAVs.info archive continued the work of preserving historical documents and making technical information available.

Commercial enterprises can benefit from such resources without paying licensing fees for the original methodology.

That is consistent with the public-access purpose of the research.

However, the absence of licensing restrictions does not make attribution unimportant.

Scientific recognition and commercial ownership are separate issues.

A business can legally construct and sell systems based on publicly available scientific knowledge while still being expected to identify the original inventor and relevant publications.

The administrator of iAVs.info reports repeated direct requests for acknowledgment, correct terminology and links to the archive.

He also reports that these requests have often received limited cooperation.

Those reports should be evaluated alongside the published company material and the underlying correspondence.

Regardless of individual motives, an important imbalance is visible.

The research and educational archive provide information freely, while businesses build commercial identities around related technologies without consistently directing their audiences to that original resource.

Commercial use of open scientific knowledge should be accompanied by accurate provenance and reasonable professional reciprocity, particularly when the knowledge was deliberately made accessible to benefit the public.

Does the documented conduct establish a coordinated effort by these companies to suppress iAVs?

The evidence establishes incomplete and inconsistent attribution, continued alternative branding and identifiable commercial incentives. It does not independently establish a coordinated suppression agreement.

There are several different forms of conduct to distinguish.

A company may fail to cite the original literature.

It may promote a commercial name more prominently than the scientific one.

It may decline to change its terminology after receiving criticism.

It may give greater attention to its own systems and services than to the research archive.

It may seek grants or institutional recognition for improvements built upon a pre-existing method.

Each of these actions can be documented and evaluated individually.

They may contribute to the marginalisation of the original scientific identity even without any agreement among the businesses.

A claim that a particular company deliberately concealed the research for financial gain would require stronger evidence linking its knowledge, intention and resulting actions.

The reported correspondence from the iAVs.info administrator is relevant to that inquiry, but the underlying records should be preserved and authenticated where necessary.

The observable pattern nevertheless has consequences.

If multiple businesses repeatedly present iAVs-derived technology primarily through other names, the cumulative effect can be reduced public recognition of the original methodology.

A coordinated conspiracy is not necessary for commercially motivated information practices to produce a distorted public understanding of scientific history.

What responsibilities should businesses have when commercialising technologies derived from established scientific research?

They should provide accurate historical attribution, distinguish their original contributions from earlier discoveries and make the supporting evidence accessible to prospective users.

For businesses promoting iAVs-derived technology, a transparent public explanation would identify McMurtry and the NCSU research group.

It would describe the original Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System and its established operating principles.

It would provide references to the original peer-reviewed publications.

It would distinguish the SRB from subsequent modifications and explain the technical reasons for those changes.

Where a company claims original innovation, it should identify the particular features or methods that it developed.

Where new performance advantages are claimed, relevant measurements should be supplied.

The company can still promote its own software, equipment, installation services, farm-management expertise and commercial accomplishments.

Accurate attribution does not prevent commercial development.

Instead, it provides customers and researchers with a clearer understanding of the technology.

It also allows public-domain science and commercial innovation to coexist without historical confusion.

Commercial success and proper scientific recognition are compatible. What is required is an accurate account of which contributions are original and which depend on earlier research.

What does the combined evidence establish about MyAquaponics, Leedana and CropsBySPC?

It establishes that these businesses promote technology closely related to an agricultural methodology developed and scientifically investigated decades earlier.

Their public materials demonstrate knowledge of iAVs to varying degrees.

MyAquaponics explicitly used the iAVs acronym while promoting the method principally as sandponics and omitting the inventor's name and original research citations from its prominent construction guide.

Leedana publicly acknowledges McMurtry and his collaborators but continues to emphasise sandponics in its branding and promotes its own commercially managed technological systems.

SPC markets farm construction, management and produce distribution under the sandponics identity and received institutional exposure through an innovation programme that explicitly identified its technology with iAVs.

The records also establish legitimate commercial activities and identifiable opportunities for financial and reputational benefit.

The administrator of iAVs.info reports repeated direct contact with all three businesses, including requests to preserve the original scientific identity and direct users toward the research archive.

These communications are relevant first-hand testimony, though their specific contents require the underlying records for independent verification.

The evidence does not justify treating every commercial omission as proof of intentional deception.

However, it supports a substantial criticism of the industry's public presentation.

The original research is not consistently made prominent or easy to locate, despite its relevance to the technologies being promoted.

This creates an imbalance between the scientific contributions that established the methodology and the commercial identities that later benefited from its dissemination.

The documented problem is that commercial promotion of the method has not consistently carried forward equally prominent recognition of its original scientific identity.

What conclusion follows for science, the public and global food-security efforts?

The original Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System was developed and scientifically investigated long before the businesses now promoting sand-based recirculating cultivation entered the field.

The NCSU research documented a practical methodology integrating fish production, vegetable cultivation, biological filtration, nutrient recycling and water conservation.

Its original purpose included improving access to nutritious food and making productive agriculture more accessible to communities facing resource constraints.

The technology was deliberately disseminated for wider public use.

Subsequent educators and advocates, including Gary Donaldson, helped preserve and distribute the information.

MyAquaponics, Leedana and CropsBySPC have promoted commercially valuable implementations of closely related technologies.

Their own published materials demonstrate that the connection to iAVs is known.

Yet the original scientific name, the inventor, the research papers and the public educational archive have not received consistent prominence across their commercial presentation.

The repeated use of sandponics compounds the problem because that term was previously used for a materially different Japanese cultivation method.

Its application to iAVs can obscure scientific provenance and introduce confusion into research literature.

The consequences extend beyond historical recognition.

Growers may be deprived of a clear route to the original experimental methodology.

Researchers may misidentify the relevant prior work.

Commercial adaptations may be mistaken for the original system.

Innovation programmes may provide recognition without making sufficiently clear which features are genuinely new.

People seeking affordable methods of producing nutritious food may encounter commercially packaged interpretations without discovering the earlier public-domain research.

These are legitimate concerns even where the precise effects on food-security outcomes cannot be quantified.

The existence of commercial incentives does not independently establish deliberate concealment by particular individuals.

However, the pattern of selective attribution and alternative branding can contribute to the marginalisation of iAVs regardless of whether the businesses involved consciously intended that result.

The scientific contribution belongs to the researchers who established it. The credit for preserving and disseminating that research belongs to those who performed that work. Later commercial implementers deserve recognition for their own demonstrated contributions, without obscuring those who came before them.

MyAquaponics, Leedana and CropsBySPC are entitled to operate businesses based on publicly available agricultural science. Their commercial freedom does not diminish the importance of accurately identifying the original invention, preserving its scientific history and enabling the public to find the research.

When commercially successful enterprises benefit from a freely shared agricultural methodology while its original name, research and educational archive remain comparatively obscure, the resulting imbalance is a legitimate failure of scientific attribution and public education.

For a technology developed partly to address food insecurity, malnutrition, water scarcity and agricultural independence, that failure matters. The value of the research is greatest when people can understand it, verify it and apply it without unnecessary dependence on the businesses that subsequently commercialised its principles.

References