How a firsthand account from February 2012 exposes the changing purpose of aquaponics education and the growing dependence on commercial suppliers
Who was Jonathan Kadish?
Kadish was an entrepreneur, aquaponics enthusiast and participant in the Aquaponics Association community, posting under the name Jonathan Kadish NYC AA Chair. He attended training with Nelson and Pade and Dr James Rakocy, giving him firsthand experience of the emerging commercial aquaponics education industry (Kadish, 2012a, 2012b).
What did Kadish reveal about Nelson and Pade's workshops?
On 11 February 2012, Kadish stated:
To be clear, in a 3 day workshop you will only learn the basics and for sure the underlying purpose of Nelson & Pade's workshops is to sell their systems.
This is particularly valuable historical evidence because Kadish was a satisfied customer describing his experience, rather than an opponent of the company (Kadish, 2012a).
Did Nelson and Pade subsequently confirm the connection between training and system sales?
Yes. Beginning in April 2012, the company introduced an incentive programme offering workshop attendees discounts on Clear Flow Aquaponic Systems, initially valid for 30 days after attending. The programme directly connected agricultural education with equipment purchases (Aqua Vista, 2012; Nelson & Pade, n.d.-a).
Why is the timing significant?
Research subsequently identified 2012 as the peak of public interest in aquaponics. Nelson and Pade were expanding their manufacturing, educational programmes, university partnerships and commercial system offerings during this period (Turnšek et al., 2020; Nelson & Pade, n.d.-b).
Kadish's comments document this commercial transformation as it was occurring.
How was scientific authority incorporated into the company's sales strategy?
In 2011, Nelson and Pade announced that James Rakocy had joined its consulting staff alongside his existing advisory position. The announcement also identified its Clear Flow systems as the only commercial aquaponics systems endorsed by Rakocy (Nelson & Pade, 2011).
Academic reputation had become a commercial selling point.
Did three days of training once provide enough knowledge to establish an integrated agricultural system?
Yes. In December 1989, Tom and Paula Speraneo attended a three-day workshop conducted by Dr Mark McMurtry at the Meadowcreek Project in Arkansas. They subsequently constructed their own system, modifying the original Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System (iAVs) by substituting gravel for sand (McMurtry, 2018; iAVs Research Archive, 2025).
Their subsequent activities profoundly influenced the development of media-based aquaponics.
What were the consequences of the Speraneos' modifications?
Replacing sand with gravel changed the filtration, moisture retention and hydraulic characteristics of the original design. The modified methodology subsequently became an influential model for media-based aquaponics.
Independent agricultural extension literature confirms that the Speraneos modified the NCSU method, used gravel instead of sand and eventually introduced rock dust as a trace-element supplement (Diver, 2006).
Consequently, later growers inherited a modified technology with different biological and nutritional requirements from the original scientifically investigated system.
Was there an example of someone receiving brief instruction and successfully implementing the original methodology?
Yes. Dr Boone Mora, a retired veterinarian, and Tim Garrett established a USDA-supported commercial-scale iAVs demonstration in North Carolina during 1992–1994 after brief initial instruction from McMurtry.
Historical accounts describe approximately one to three days of instruction. The operators subsequently constructed and managed the installation themselves, with McMurtry overseas during its establishment (iAVs Research Archive, 2025, 2026).
How substantial was Mora's achievement?
Mora and Garrett established an approximately 10,000-square-foot greenhouse producing fish and vegetables for local markets. Their published account describes selling produce to supermarkets, while their demonstration attracted more than 1,500 visitors (McClintic, 1994; Mora, 1994).
The project's significance lies in demonstrating practical technology transfer: people with limited previous experience could construct, operate and document the methodology independently.
Did Mora subsequently share his knowledge freely?
Yes. In July 1994, Mora circulated a detailed letter explaining construction, fish production, irrigation, crop management, operational mistakes and practical recommendations.
He explicitly credited McMurtry and Professor Douglas Sanders, acknowledging that the methodology originated in their research. He also invited others to contribute knowledge that could be shared among growers (Mora, 1994).
This was agricultural education directed towards collective improvement and independent production.
What does the comparison between Mora and Nelson and Pade reveal?
Mora received brief instruction and subsequently constructed and operated a substantial production facility. Nelson and Pade's three-day workshop provided introductory knowledge while encouraging participants to purchase commercially manufactured systems and undertake additional training.
The distinction is between teaching a reproducible methodology and providing education organised partly around the purchase of a supplier's products.
Did Kadish himself identify problems with the complexity of UVI-based aquaponics?
Yes. On 23 October 2012, Kadish questioned the space occupied by separate clarification, net filtration, Matala filtration and degassing tanks. He argued that a suitably designed growing bed could perform these functions while also producing food (Kadish, 2012b).
His observation identifies a central engineering problem: separating biological functions across numerous components consumes valuable production space and increases infrastructure requirements.
How expensive did Nelson and Pade's commercial systems become?
A company catalogue produced around 2019 advertised its Small Commercial System at US$59,995, its Large Commercial System at US$79,995 and its Expanded Large Commercial System at US$189,995. Greenhouses and several additional production components were listed separately (Nelson & Pade, c. 2019).
These historical catalogue prices illustrate the substantial capital requirements associated with the company's commercial model.
What equipment was included in the Small Commercial System?
The US$59,995 package included four fish tanks, separate filtration tanks, a ZDEP waste-management system, a raft tank, a living filter bed, plant propagation equipment, plumbing and aeration.
The company estimated five to eight hours of daily greenhouse labour and required at least 3,300 square feet of protected or indoor space (Nelson & Pade, c. 2019, p. 42).
The considerable equipment and management requirements create substantial barriers for resource-limited growers.
What is particularly revealing about the company's Living Filter Bed?
Its purpose is to provide a growing environment where discharged organic material decomposes and supplies nutrients to plants.
The catalogue offered this capability as an additional US$13,000 package for its Large Commercial System, requiring more greenhouse space, additional labour and a different system configuration (Nelson & Pade, c. 2019, p. 43).
The original NCSU methodology incorporated organic waste decomposition, nutrient recovery and horticultural production within its principal sand biofilter decades earlier (McMurtry et al., 1990).
Is there a fundamental economic problem with this additional equipment?
Yes. Separating filtration, nutrient recovery and crop production into multiple components increases construction requirements and creates additional operating expenses.
Integrating these functions within one biologically active growing environment reduces the need for separate treatment infrastructure. This was a central engineering advantage of the original NCSU methodology (McMurtry et al., 1997a).
Every additional component must produce sufficient agricultural benefits to justify its total cost.
Did commercial aquaponics education become a significant source of industry revenue?
Yes. Love et al. (2015) found that selling aquaponics-related non-food products and services was associated with higher odds of reported profitability.
European research subsequently found that approximately 72% of surveyed participants generated income from selling aquaponics knowledge through courses, consultancy, system design or visits, while approximately 25% reported income from food sales (Turnšek et al., 2020).
Kadish's 2012 observation anticipated a commercial pattern subsequently documented by independent researchers.
Why is the number of systems sold an inadequate measure of agricultural success?
Kadish reported that Nelson and Pade had achieved approximately 173,000 square feet of installations by February 2012 (Kadish, 2012a).
Installed production area measures the supplier's market penetration. Whether those installations subsequently produced profitable food, recovered their capital costs or remained operational requires separate evidence.
Equipment sales and successful farming are different economic outcomes.
What was the original purpose of the NCSU technology?
In 1988, Professor H. Douglas Gross of NCSU's Office of International Programs identified iAVs as a means of improving nutrition, household income and self-sufficiency among limited-resource farmers.
He specifically emphasised locally available inputs, relatively simple management requirements, water conservation and suitability for challenging environments (Gross, 1988).
Accessibility was central to the technology's intended application.
Why is the commercial model particularly problematic for food-insecure communities?
High capital costs, specialised equipment, imported components, extensive training requirements and recurring technical support increase the financial barriers to food production.
Communities experiencing food and water insecurity benefit from technologies that can be constructed locally, maintained affordably and operated independently.
The original NCSU research demonstrated how biological integration and intermittent irrigation could reduce equipment requirements while producing fish and valuable vegetable crops (McMurtry et al., 1990, 1997b).
What should agricultural education accomplish?
Agricultural education should give people the knowledge and skills necessary to produce food successfully and independently. Commercial equipment purchases should be optional decisions based on demonstrated benefits, realistic costs and local requirements.
The success of an educational programme should ultimately be measured by what its students can accomplish.
Conclusion
Jonathan Kadish's February 2012 account documents an important turning point in aquaponics history: agricultural education was becoming closely integrated with commercial equipment sales.
Nelson and Pade's subsequent workshop purchasing incentives, expanded training programmes and expensive system packages demonstrate the development of this business model.
The earlier experiences of the Speraneos and Boone Mora illustrate how briefly communicated agricultural knowledge could enable independent construction and operation. Mora's experience is especially important because he implemented the original methodology and subsequently shared his practical knowledge, including mistakes, for the benefit of others.
The original NCSU research was developed for productive, water-efficient agriculture using relatively simple technology. Its potential contribution to resource-limited communities was recognised as early as 1988.
For food and water security, the priorities should be affordability, biological efficiency, local construction, accurate scientific education and independence from unnecessary commercial infrastructure.
References
-
Aqua Vista (2012). Aquaponics News #2. 15 May 2012. Reproduces Nelson and Pade's announcement of its workshop purchasing incentive programme.
https://viceroy-limited.blogspot.com/2012/05/ -
Diver, S. (2006). Aquaponics—Integration of Hydroponics with Aquaculture. ATTRA Sustainable Agriculture Information Service, National Center for Appropriate Technology.
https://agrisynergy.com/uploads/3/4/3/3/34339224/attra-aquaponics.pdf -
Gross, H. D. (1988). The Aqua-Vegeculture System. North Carolina State University, Office of International Programs.
https://iavs.info/the-aqua-vegeculture-system/ -
iAVs Research Archive (2025). The Forgotten History of Aquaponics. Historical account of the Speraneo workshop and subsequent technology transfer.
https://iavs.info/the-forgotten-history-of-aquaponics/ -
iAVs Research Archive (2026). iAVs Research Group. Historical documentation of the Boone Mora and Tim Garrett commercial demonstration.
https://iavs.info/iavs-research-group/ -
Kadish, J. (2012a). Response to Commercial Course. Aquaponic Gardening forum, 11 February 2012, 1:09 am. Firsthand account of Nelson and Pade's three-day workshop and its commercial purpose, preserved in a documentary screenshot.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/commercial-course?id=4778851%3ATopic%3A273719&page=3#comments -
Kadish, J. (2012b). Response to Basement Flating Raft System for the City Resident. Aquaponic Gardening forum, 23 October 2012. Discussion of UVI filtration requirements and the advantages of integrating filtration within growing beds.
https://aquaponicgardening.ning.com/forum/topics/basement-flating-raft-system-for-the-city-resident -
Love, D. C., Fry, J. P., Li, X., Hill, E. S., Genello, L., Semmens, K., & Thompson, R. E. (2015). Commercial aquaponics production and profitability: Findings from an international survey. Aquaculture, 435, 67–74.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2014.09.023 -
McClintic, D. (1994). Double-duty greenhouse. The Furrow, March–April, 41–42. Reproduced and discussed at
https://iavs.info/an-article-on-the-iavs-usda-commercial-trial-conducted-by-mora-garrett/ -
McMurtry, M. R. (2018). Correspondence to the FAO Director-General, 20 April 2018. Firsthand historical account of the Speraneos' introduction to iAVs and subsequent modifications.
https://iavs.info/fao-israeli-malfeasance-wrt-iavs/ -
McMurtry, M. R., Nelson, P. V., Sanders, D. C., & Hodges, L. (1990). Sand culture of vegetables using recirculated aquacultural effluents. Applied Agricultural Research, 5(4), 280–284.
https://iavs.info/sand-culture-of-vegetables-using-recirculated-aquacultural-effluents/ -
McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., & Hodson, R. G. (1997a). Effects of biofilter/culture tank volume ratios on productivity of a recirculating fish/vegetable co-culture system. Journal of Applied Aquaculture, 7(4), 33–51.
https://doi.org/10.1300/J028v07n04_03 -
McMurtry, M. R., Sanders, D. C., Cure, J. D., Hodson, R. G., Haning, B. C., & St. Amand, P. C. (1997b). Efficiency of water use of an integrated fish/vegetable co-culture system. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, 28(4), 420–428.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-7345.1997.tb00290.x -
Mora, B. (1994). Letter concerning the construction and operation of the aqua-vegeculture demonstration, 6 July 1994.
https://iavs.info/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/iavs-Boone-Mora-email-1994.pdf -
Nelson & Pade (2011). Big News, Exciting Developments. Commercial announcement concerning James Rakocy's consultancy, advisory position and product endorsement.
https://aquaponics.com/nelson-and-pade-blog/big-news-exciting-developments/ -
Nelson & Pade (c. 2019). Aquaponics: Planning, Systems, Training, Support, Supplies. Commercial product catalogue, particularly pp. 42–44.
https://www.aquanet.com/uploads/curriculum-vitae/nelson-and-pade-aquaponics-50809.pdf -
Nelson & Pade (n.d.-a). Incentive Program. System-purchasing discounts for attendees of the three-day Aquaponics Master Class.
https://aquaponics.com/incentive-program/ -
Nelson & Pade (n.d.-b). History and Achievements. Corporate history documenting manufacturing, education, university partnerships and commercial expansion.
https://aquaponics.com/about/history-and-achievements/ -
Turnšek, M., Joly, A., Thorarinsdottir, R., & Junge, R. (2020). Challenges of commercial aquaponics in Europe: Beyond the hype. Water, 12(1), 306.
https://doi.org/10.3390/w12010306